The rule that sorts most common trees
Why leaf arrangement, opposite or alternate, is the first question to ask of an unknown tree.
Ask first whether the buds and leaves grow in pairs or one at a time. This answer divides the common trees of a stand into two smaller groups, and an unknown tree can then be checked against a short list. Opposite means a pair of buds or leaves faces each other at the same point on the twig. Alternate means each bud or leaf sits at its own point, usually staggered up the stem.
Two arrangements
- Opposite
- Two buds or leaves join the twig at the same node, on opposite sides.
- Alternate
- One bud or leaf joins the twig at each node, turning from side to side up the stem.
- Node
- The swollen point on a twig where a leaf or bud joins. Leaf scars and buds sit here.
Check the twig, not a single leaf. Leaves fall, are chewed or are torn, and a lone leaf can mislead. Look at the nodes near the tip of a shoot, where the newest growth is, and count the buds or leaf scars at each one.
A short method
- Choose a shoot of the current season's growth, the thinner stem near the end of a branch.
- Look at the first three nodes from the tip.
- If a pair faces each other at each node, the tree is opposite.
- If one bud or leaf sits at each node, the tree is alternate.
- Note whether each leaf is simple (one blade) or compound (several leaflets on one stalk).
Opposite arrangement is found on ash, sycamore, field maple, Norway maple, horse chestnut, elder and dogwood. Alternate arrangement is found on silver birch, rowan, oak, beech, hazel, elm and plane. A few shrubs and climbers differ, so the arrangement narrows the field without naming the tree on its own.
| Arrangement | Common example | Look-alike to check | Key sign |
|---|---|---|---|
| Opposite | Common ash | Elder | Ash buds are black; elder shoots show pale pith when cut |
| Opposite | Sycamore | Field maple | Sycamore lobes are coarse and toothed; field maple lobes are smaller and rounded |
| Alternate | Silver birch | Downy birch | Silver birch twigs are slender with small pale dots; downy birch shoots are hairy |
| Alternate | Rowan | Common ash | Rowan buds are brown and alternate; ash buds are black and opposite |
Once the arrangement is known, the rest of the twig narrows the choice. Bud colour and shape, leaf lobing and the seeds that fall in autumn each add a further sign. Sycamore carries paired, winged seeds that spin as they fall. Ash carries single-winged seeds in hanging bunches.
For a fuller method on buds, see reading buds on a bare twig. Terms used here are defined in the glossary. Individual entries on common ash, sycamore and silver birch give the full set of signs for each tree.